The Justice System

Why do young people offend? And what happens if you do?
A young man sits in silhouette at the end of a tunnel

Why do young people offend?

There are all sorts of reasons why young people commit crimes.

According to a report by Civitas (a group that studies society), approximately 70,000 school-aged children enter the youth justice system each year and nearly half of first-time offenders are young adults… But why is this happening?

Why young people offend:

  • Problems at home or with their family
  • Peer pressure
  • Boredom
  • Feeling excluded, angry and unhappy
  • Problems with drugs and alcohol.

But it needn’t be this way.

The Youth Offending Service

The Youth Offending Service (YOS) can recommend schemes and projects to help young people and their families address their problems and improve their lives. These include support with addressing anger and self-esteem issues and help you learn at your own pace.

Crucial: There is also a Restorative Justice Team within the YOS which supports the victims of youth crime.

The Pre-Court Team

The Oxfordshire team consists of two police officers who are seconded to the YOS. They wear uniform and their duties consist solely of delivering Youth Restorative Disposals (YRD’s), Reprimands and Final Warnings. The team also signpost to other agencies for intervention.

What happens at court?

What to expect if you have to go to court.

When a young person has been charged with an offence, the Police will decide whether you need to go to Court. Young People may also need to go to court for re-offending after a Youth Conditional Caution.

Different types of court

There are three different types of court in England and Wales:

  1. The Crown Court
  2. Magistrate’s Court
  3. Youth Court.

The Youth Court usually deals with young people. This is a closed court so no one is allowed to attend apart from those directly related to your case and your parents.

Before court

Before you appear in court you will need to get a solicitor to represent you. Normally you will be entitled to legal aid which means that your fees will be paid, unless your parents or guardians choose to pay for someone else. If you still have no solicitor when it’s time for you to appear, ask the court for the duty solicitor.

Make sure that you are able to attend court on the date given – only in exceptional circumstances can you not attend. Make arrangements with your Parent(s) or Carer(s) to attend on time. You have to be at court at 9:45 am unless you are given a different time.

Who will be at court?

  • The Usher keeps track of the defendants and their solicitors. They decide the order of the cases for the day. This can depend on when solicitors are available.
  • The Magistrates (also called ‘the bench’) are people from the local community who have been asked to serve as magistrates. They aren’t usually lawyers but they have had training. They have to follow rules and receive guidance from the court's clerk and a justice's manual. There are normally three magistrates present. Sometimes there might only be two. They pass judgement. If only one person is present, that will be a Judge - legally qualified and able to act on their own.
  • The Clerk helps guide the magistrates on legal aspects. Unlike the magistrates, the clerk is legally qualified and can supply legal reasons for decisions made.
  • The Prosecutor  is a solicitor who is bringing the case against you on behalf of the Crown Prosecution Service. They will normally speak first, and will tell the magistrates about the alleged crime (you are innocent until proven guilty). They will use police and witness statements to strengthen their case. They will share any previous convictions but only if you are found guilty.
  • The Defence is the solicitor acting on your behalf. They will speak to you before you go into the court and find out more about the crime. They will plan with you how to move ahead with your case. You need to tell them everything that happened so that they can be prepared for anything that comes up in court.
  • The YOS Representative will be in the court to tell the magistrates any information that they have about you, including any previous sentences and any risk issues relevant to sentencing. They also ensure you understand any sentence, write some reports, and keep a record of what happens in court.

Criminal Justice ladder

From misdemeanours to serious crimes, how will your case be dealt with?

Youth Restorative Disposal (YRD) -or Community Disposal

Given to a young person for a first time offence. The offence must be minor in nature.  If the young person is a Looked After Child (LAC) they may be referred directly to support services by the police, this is called Diversion.

Youth Caution

Given to a young person for a first time offence which is too serious for a Youth Restorative Disposal.

There must have been enough evidence to prosecute you. The record will be kept by police until your 18th birthday and can be used in future court proceedings.

A Youth Caution has voluntary conditions or no powers attached if the young person doesn't comply.

Youth Conditional Caution

Imposes compulsory conditions on the young person which could include things such as attending an agreed number of substance misuse sessions, a curfew, anger management or fines/compensation. If the Young Person does not comply, the police have the power to withdraw the caution and place them in front of a court.

Crucial: To be eligible for any of the above a Young Person has to admit their guilt. There is no absolute limit to how many a Young Person could have – each case is based on the circumstances/its own merits.

Youth Restorative Disposals only show up when vetted by the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) (formally CRB checks) as having been spoken to by the police - not an admission of guilt. Youth Cautions and Youth Conditional Cautions will show up for life on the DBS (till 100 yrs. old) as an admission of guilt. (Police record only). A DBS check may be needed for certain jobs or voluntary work - like working with children, or in healthcare, or when applying to foster or adopt a child.

Referral Order

A statutory Order which lasts from 3 to 12 months.  A panel of trained volunteers meet the young person and YOS Officer after sentencing. The panel then puts in place a programme of intervention which is supervised by the YOS Officer.  If the young person doesn’t comply, they are ‘Breached’ and placed before the court again. They have a criminal record which last for the duration of the Order. When the Order is completed, the criminal record is ‘spent’, however you must make all future employers aware of your Referral Order.

Youth Rehabilitation Order (YRO)

The criminal record is resurrected and is then ‘live’ for the rest of the young person’s life and must be told to future employers, colleges or universities.

There are many interventions such as supervision, curfews, electronic monitoring, drug treatment and testing to name a few, which can be tacked on to the YRO.  The young person must comply with all aspects of the Order.  If not, it will be extended or occasionally, the young person will be sent to Prison.

Prison Sentence

Any young person up to the age of 18 years can be sentenced to a term of custody in either a Secure Training Centre or a Young Offenders Institution.  When they are released they will be supervised by the YOS on licence.

Crucial: Alternatives to custody are Intensive Fostering or Intensive Supervision and Surveillance.

Leave a Comment